Gender Differences and Perceptions on leadership
Leadership is often perceived through a gendered lens, with assumptions about how men and women lead influencing how they are evaluated. While both genders exhibit effective leadership, studies have shown that their styles often differ, and societal biases can influence how these differences are perceived.
The following research explores key gender differences in leadership styles and the stereotypes that affect how male and female leaders are viewed.
Transformational Leadership:
Women at the Forefront
Transformational leadership, characterised by empathy, collaboration, and inspiration, is often associated with female leaders. Women tend to adopt a more participative and democratic leadership style, emphasising mentorship and empowering their teams.
Studies suggest that women score higher than men on transformational leadership measures, making them effective at fostering innovation and team cohesion.
A meta-analysis found that women are more likely than men to adopt transformational leadership styles, which are linked to higher levels of employee satisfaction and organisational success.
Source: Eagly, Johannesen-Schmidt, & van Engen (2003)
Transactional Leadership:
Men and Task-Oriented Approaches
Men are more likely to exhibit transactional leadership styles, which focus on goal-setting, performance, and rewards. This approach emphasises task completion, monitoring, and corrective action.
While effective in certain contexts, this style can sometimes be perceived as less collaborative or emotionally intelligent.
Research from Van Engen and Willemsen (2004) shows that men often score higher on transactional leadership scales, which are traditionally linked to directive and authoritative management approaches.
Source: National Institute for Health (2004)
Laissez-Faire Leadership:
Gender Gaps in Delegation
Laissez-faire leadership, where minimal oversight is provided, can be perceived differently when exhibited by men versus women.
While male leaders using this style may be seen as trusting their team, female leaders adopting a hands-off approach are more likely to be perceived as disengaged or lacking authority.
Women in leadership positions who exhibit laissez-faire leadership styles are often judged more harshly than their male counterparts.
Source: Carli and Eagly (2016)
Subscribe for more
✓ Hear the latest STories
✓ 1,000+ facts
Perceptions and Bias:
How Society Views Male and Female Leaders
“Double Bind” for Women Leaders
Women in leadership often face a “double bind”—they are expected to be nurturing and empathetic, but when they exhibit assertiveness or authority, they may be viewed as too aggressive.
Conversely, if they adhere to stereotypically feminine traits, they risk being perceived as ineffective or weak.
Statistic:
A study found that women are 1.4 times more likely than men to be perceived as “too aggressive” or “bossy” when demonstrating strong leadership qualities.
Source: Centre for Creative Leadership (n.d)
Confidence vs. Competence: A Gender Gap
Men are often perceived as more competent and decisive leaders, even when women demonstrate the same skills and expertise.
Women, however, have to prove their competence repeatedly, whereas men benefit from a “halo effect” of assumed competence.
Statistic:
A report by McKinsey & Company (2022) showed that only 86 women are promoted to manager roles for every 100 men, despite equal qualifications.
Source: Women in Tech, (2022)
Why These Perceptions Matter:
Impact on Leadership Opportunities
These societal perceptions create significant barriers for women in leadership, limiting access to higher-level roles and perpetuating gender disparities at the executive level.
Organisations that embrace diverse leadership styles and challenge these biases tend to experience higher levels of innovation, employee engagement, and financial performance.
Why These Perceptions Matter
Impact on Leadership Opportunities
These societal perceptions create significant barriers for women in leadership, limiting access to higher-level roles and perpetuating gender disparities at the executive level.
Organisations that embrace diverse leadership styles and challenge these biases tend to experience higher levels of innovation, employee engagement, and financial performance.
Gender Differences and Perceptions on leadership
Statistics to Remember:
69% of people believe that men and women have different leadership styles, with women perceived as more collaborative and men seen as more authoritative.
Women score 6% higher than men on overall leadership effectiveness across various leadership competencies.
44% of senior leadership positions globally are held by women, yet only 10% hold CEO roles.
Women are twice as likely as men to be criticised for being too aggressive in leadership roles.
Organisations with more women in leadership report a 15% higher profitability rate.
Leave your thoughts